Skip to main content

Best Pizza in Town

Big pies. Bigger taste.

Pizza in Kansas City and Olathe

Pizza 51 opened at 51st and Oak in 2004. You can now find us in Midtown KC and downtown Olathe.
Slices and 26-inch pies

Slices and 26-inch pies

Order pizza by the slice or choose a pie up to 26 inches. Salads, sandwiches, and cold beer are on the menu too.
The corner of 51st and Oak

The corner of 51st and Oak

Pizza 51 opened in a former Brookside gas station at 51st and Oak on September 15, 2004.

Hands down the best pizza in the area. Having grown up in NY I tend to be picky about the pizza I eat. These had a nice, crispy bottom, a thin crust but a great pillowy crust. The sauce was a wonderful mix between sweetness and acidity and not too heavily seasoned. Importantly, the pizza was not at all greasy like I've seen others around town try their hands at NY style pizza. My kids loved it as well!

John G.

The BEST pizza and it’s so delicious every time! A nice little gem of a place in downtown Olathe. We love their side salads and speciality slices- bigger than your hand! Maureen and Allison are the friendliest folks to greet you; love their humor and personalities! The atmosphere is fun and I love being able to see them toss the pizza crust from the kitchen window.

Cameron B.

This is some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. And just the coolest spot. With the greatest people. Have eaten in a couple of times, then my mom wanted it for her 80th birthday party. The restaurant crew decorated the outside of the boxes with happy birthday messages. It was so sweet! I really can't recommend this place too much. They're the best!

Rick S.

Love the open concept of the kitchen! Exciting to watch the food be prepared. Decor is great. Noise level is acceptable and right on par with everywhere else. Casual- super casual! Temp inside is perfect! Not too cold, not too hot! Service is phenomenal. Watching the trains go by is a highlight My warm Italian Sub was great with just the right amount of heat. (You can order it hot or cold).

Elle M.

I love when a restaurant repurposes an old local building and Pizza 51 is located in an old auto shop in downtown Olathe. You order your food at the front counter and they deliver your food to the table. The three of us each ordered an individual slice and all agreed it was delicious. I love the thin, foldable pizza loaded with toppings…dipped in ranch. Really good ranch 9/10. We sat outside on the patio where thankfully there were covered parts to keep us out of the sun. Overall pros…

Aaron R.

Pizza 51 Rewards

Pizza 51 Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Frequently asked questions

What are you known for?
What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Olathe, Westwood, Westwood Hills, Mission Woods, Mission Hills, Overland Park, Fairway, Kansas City, Roeland Park, Western 49-63, Sunset Hill, Eastern 49-63, Mission, Prairie Village, Blue Hills, Southmoreland, Lackmans, West Plaza, Lenexa, and Countryside.

Our locations